mock-up of pediatric urogenital surgery

Sequential Surgical Illustration

Urethral Advancement and Circumcision to Repair a
Case of Distal Hypospadias

May 2020

Overview

A sequential surgical guide that highlights the pertinent steps of a pediatric urogenital procedure. The final product is inked (digitally) in black and white.




Supervisor

Michael Corrin, Associate Professor, Teaching Stream & Associate Director of the MScBMC Graduate Program at the University of Toronto


Content Advisor

Dr. Darius Bagli, Paediatric Urologist, MDCM, FRCSC, FAAAP, FACS, Professor in the University of Toronto's Department of Surgery


Location

University of Toronto Missisauga

The Hospital for Sick Children (SickKids)


Audience

Surgical residents


Roles and Responsibilities

Researcher, illustrator. Partnered with Willow Yang for in-person surgical observation.


Tools

Illustrator, Procreate

Challenges

Neither of us are surgeons (obviously), so the biggest challenge was determining what novel information a surgical resident would need to know to complete the procedure. What's common in this field (e.g. a type of stitch) and what is specific to this procedure? This was especially difficult because we could only watch the procedure once and there is a uniqueness to each surgery.

Observation

Surgery waits for no one—we're lucky a surgeon was nice enough to let us observe! We wake up at 4am to get to the hospital by 7am (neither of us are morning risers).

We divide our tasks to optimize our observation window: Willow sketches and I communicate with the surgeon and surgical nurse to record the tools, anatomy involved, as well as notes about each step in the procedure.

Willow’s sketches of patient position, tools, and excisions form the foundation of subsequent illustrations.

Willow’s sketches form the foundation of our drafts.

Research + Filling in Gaps

Immediately after observing the surgery, we meet to compare notes, sketches, and construct a written description of the procedure. The purpose is to analyze for the gaps in our understanding. I also draw thumbnails to target gaps in my spatial understanding, and how different instruments were held.

In reviewing the literature, it's clear that there are several ways to fix a distal hypospadias and perform a circumcision, but none are exactly like the technique that Dr. Bagli employed. To solve this issue, we pool together our research and our observation notes, and refine the steps of the work. We create key questions to ask Dr. Bagli and the surgical resident to fill in these gaps (they're incredibly intimidating and incredibly generous!).

Initial copy and thumbnails of the urethral advancement and circumcision, a combination of our observation notes and the literature.

Iterate, Iterate, Iterate...

Every week, we meet with Professor Corrin to critique our illustrations. We learn from each other, our peers, and resolve our misunderstandings of the anatomy and steps, reworking several drafts. It gets better after each iteration, but not without a lot of work!

Surgical iterations.

Design Comprehensive

We each reach a sufficiently viable product and share one of the copies with Dr. Bagli to confirm the accuracy of our illustrations. I'm not sure how he had the time but his annotations and mark-ups clarify our understanding once more.

Final comprehensive illustration.

Outcome

Here’s the final illustration of the procedure. Lacking the traditional studio tools due to the ongoing pandemic, I inked it in Procreate.

Cover page

Page 1 and 2

Page 3 and 4

Page 5

Reflection

This was a frustrating yet incredibly rewarding project to be part of. Adopting a consistent and rapid-iterative approach to developing drafts helped to identify and resolve comprehensive problems in the beginning.

Acknowledgements

You can achieve spectacular goals with a great mentor and collaborator. Immense gratitude to Professor Corrin, as always, for his superb guidance; Dr. Bagli for his patience in answering our inane emails; and of course, Willow Yang, a talented designer.

Works Consulted

Here is my bibliography (PDF). It includes text and anything else I found constructive in my research. Feel to reach out about any resources and if you have any questions!